Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggiano

[26 Jul 2010 | By | 8 Comments]

4617971479 f1078e01611 Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggiano

Spending a year in Italy added so many dimensions to my culinary experience and food knowledge—I hardly know where to begin. I like the idea of revisiting individual ingredients, now that I am back-in-the-states and reflecting on my experience.

When I was in Italy it was about tasting the flavors of each season, traveling around Tuscany, stopping by a frantoio to taste olive oil and sampling Chiantis while sitting among their vines. I recently wrote a post about Buffalo Mozzarella, researched and summarized Vin Santo (Tuscany’s traditional dessert wine), and have written specific posts on Morellino di Scansano (red wine, southern Tuscany), artichokes (filled stalls in markets all spring) and Fava Beans. I am still in learning mode (this might be a perpetual thing for me… like a redundant state-of-mind, but I digress), and loving every minute.

Italy provides an enticing list of ingredients to consider—Grana Padano and Parmigiano Reggiano are two of them. If I wasn’t paying attention, I would have thought both were just ‘Parmesan cheese.’ Actually ‘Parmesan’ is more of a catch-all term, frequently used in America, referring to hard, dry, sharp-flavored Italianesque cheeses. That serves a function, but so does knowing just a bit more—and appreciating the differences between heirloom Italian cheeses.

4623986742 0a6839e4c8 Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggiano

Parmesan is a nick-name, but stems from Parmigano Reggiano: a cheese from the Parma and/or Reggio Emilia region of Italy. A similar cheese from a neighboring region is Grana Padano. Monks in northern Italy’s Po valley encouraged the breeding of cattle for food/milk as early as the 11th century; the excess milk was made into long-aging cheese in what we know today as Grana Padano (the same story applies to Parmigiano Reggiano, 2 centuries later).

Both cheeses are DOP controlled: they have specific methods for processing and again, are from designated geographical zones and each wheel of cheese is tested for quality. They are both cooked, pressed, semi-hard cheeses made from cow’s milk. Both use high quality milk, rennet and salt; while aging, the wheels are humidity and temperature controlled, cleaned and flipped regularly. The cheeses’ colors and flavors differ, largely due to different grasses grazed by milk-producing cows.

Parmigiano reggiano logo Grana Padano v. Parmigiano ReggianoParmigiano-Reggiano

  • it must age at least 12 months.
  • made with mix of whole and skim milk.
  • it is produced in Parma, Modena and Reggio Emilia, as well as parts of Mantua and Bologna.
  • a golden straw color, which deepens with age.
  • 3 seals associated with age:
  1. the red seal (aged 18 mo.; flavors of milk, grass, fruit/vegetables),
  2. the silver seal (aged 22 months; balance of sweet and savory, added notes of melted butter and nuts), and
  3. the gold seal (aged 30 months; crumbly, nutty and spicy).

grana Grana Padano v. Parmigiano ReggianoGrana Padano

  • must age at least 9 months.servizi01 Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggiano
  • made with partially skimmed milk.
  • produced in Lombardy, Piedmont, Trentino and Veneto regions (the Po River Valley).
  • color ranges from white to straw, taste from sweet to pungent (with age)
  • more white spots/crystals appearing [appropriately] with age.
  • young Grana Padano will taste clean and milky (aged 9 mo.), aged longer will bring notes of straw, butter and hay (aged 16 mo.); the reserve cheese adds layers of dried/roasted fruit and beef stock (aged 22 mo.).

 

Cheesy facts:

  • it takes 60 gallons of part-skim, unpasteurized cow’s milk to make one 80 LB wheel of cheese.
  • each pound of cheese contains the concentrated nutrients of 2 gallons of milk.
  • there are big differences within a grade of cheese, primarily due to aging; optimal aging is around 2 years.
  • the more the cheese ages, the more crumbly/grainy the texture.
  • ‘Padano’ means ‘of the Po River’ (river’s Latin name Padus) and ‘Grana’ means grainy—referring to the cheese’s grainy texture.
  • four million wheels of Grana are made per year versus two million wheels of Parmigiano.

So next time you are grabbing ‘Parmesan’ at your grocers, look a little closer. Does it say Grana Padano or Parmigiano Reggiano? Are their stamps or symbols? How long has it been aged? Is it white or golden yellow? Pay attention while you taste the cheeses, and over time, you will notice subtle differences. Picture Italian cattle grazing on grasses from different regions of Northern Italy. It is their grazing—and age-old, well-preserved techniques and care—that deliver these unique, divine and nutrient-rich cheeses.

facebook Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggianogoogleplus Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggianopinterest Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggianostumbleupon Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggianotwitter Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggiano
This entry was posted in food focus, food., Italian food & wine and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

8 Comments »

  • The Italian Dish said (26 July 2010 at 8:35 am):

    I love them both!

  • Chiara said (28 July 2010 at 10:50 pm):

    Wait, you are back in the US? I must have been distracted and didn’t know it… must go back and ready your recent posts!
    Being from Lombardy myself, I prefer grana padano, but both are delicious cheeses I always enjoy eating, as is, or of course use to make risotto!

  • difference between: Asiago, Pecorino, Parmesan and Romano cheese | Talk of Tomatoes said (29 July 2010 at 12:41 pm):

    [...] talking « Grana Padano v. Parmigiano Reggiano [...]

  • Stefania said (29 July 2010 at 4:42 pm):

    I would go for Grana Padano…simply because I’m from the Veneto region! My mum regularly sends me little slices of Grana through friends who come to visit me in the UK…she says that the one she sends me has a different smell, a sell of home! ah ah!

  • Risotto with Zucchini, Lemon and Black Pepper said (3 August 2010 at 7:06 am):

    [...] will stop the cooking process. You want your risotto to be vigorously boiling at all times. Grated cheese always gets added at the end of the cooking process, and if you want to make your risotto extra [...]

  • melanie said (23 August 2010 at 10:28 pm):

    Recently I asked about this @ whole foods & the lady behind the cheese counter told me they were the same thing just aged different & different quality. That we use parm reggiano instead of grana padana here! I think from reading she was wrong sounds like they have different flavors! I left thinking same cheese different quality? Help!

  • Pasta Salad with Pesto and Peas. | Talk of Tomatoes said (12 May 2011 at 11:48 am):

    [...] that =’s homemade; find recipe and mayonnaise-making method here) 1/2 cup Parmesan Cheese (or Grana Padano – yum! Ideally you bought a wedge and create large shavings or gratings so this glorious [...]

  • Estelle said (27 July 2011 at 12:51 pm):

    I tasted Grano Pedano for the first time today because Ina Garten suggested it. I am loving the flavor and will buy more..Actually I love both Reggiano and Pedano. Can’t go wrong with either onel